Skip to main navigation menu Skip to main content Skip to site footer

Comparative Analysis of Smartphones and Survey-Grade GNSS Receivers for Parcel Boundary Determination

Abstract

This paper advances the existing body of knowledge on the suitability of accuracy derivable from the use of smartphones for cadastral mapping. Zenvus App software was installed on two smartphones of a different make. A set of dual-frequency GPS Promark 3 receivers and two different smartphones of different make were used for data acquisition. Observations were carried out at the boundaries of ten parcels of land, comprising 46 boundary points. Coordinates of these points were obtained using Differential Global Positioning System (DGPS) observation in static mode and two android smartphones (Samsung A70 and Tecno Spark 3 Pro).  Mean score, root means square error, and one-way analysis of variance was used to show significant differences in the equipment used.  Overall, both the accuracy (mean) and precision (RMSE) were lower than those obtained by Differential GPS. A one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was calculated on the values of both X and Y.  For X, the analysis was not significant, F (1, 45)= 0.88, p= 0.419 and for Y, the analysis was also not significant, F(1,45) =0.97, p=0.383. The total RMSE shows that coordinates of points as obtained by the Samsung smartphone (3.368) was more precise than Tecno (4.041). However, the two smartphones (Tecno and Samsung) were less accurate than differential GPS. This implies that there is a 95% chance that the errors in the estimates are less than 6.993m (for Tecno) and 5.848m (for Samsung) respectively. The variation in the observations obtainable with smartphones affects both linear and polygon estimates. The study concluded that the magnitude of these errors is significant in cadastral survey practices and hence not suitable for use. It is recommended that further studies be carried out on the use of the Zenvus app on centimeter grade smartphones probably this could yield a better result suitable for cadastral mapping.

Keywords

Demarcation, Accuracy, Zenvus, GPS

PDF

Author Biography

Caleb Olutayo Oluwadare

Dr. Oluwadare is a senior lecturer in Department of Surveying and Geoinformatics, Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile Ife Nigeria. He is a registered surveyor. He specializes in using Remote Sensing and GIS technology for land administration and solving environmental problems.

Mary Idera Salami

Mary is a graduate of  Surveying and Geoinformatics, Obafemi Awolowo University Ile Ife. She possesses the technical skills to maneuver geospatial artificial intelligence, such as ArcGIS and Machine learning in correlation geospatial science. Her research efforts have been focused on the  accuracy derivable from the use of a mobile application for cadastral mapping by comparing the accuracy of Zenvus Mobile Application and Differential Global Positioning System. She is also pursuing her research drive further to Masters level.


References

  1. American Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing (1993). ASPRS Accuracy Standards for Large-Scale Maps, USA.
  2. Basiouka, S. & Potsiou, C. (2012). “VGI in Cadastre: a Greek experiment to investigate the potential of crowdsourcing techniques in Cadastral Mapping". Survey Review, 44(325): 153-161
  3. Basiouka, S.; Potsiou C. and Bakogiannis E (2014). The OpenStreetMap for cadastral purposes: An application using VGI for official processes in urban areas. FIG Commission 3 Workshop on Geospatial Crowdsourcing and VGI: Establishment of SDI & SIM held at Bologna, Italy, 4-7 November.
  4. Cetl, V., Ioannidis, C., Dalyot, S., Doytsher, Y., Felus, Y., Haklay, M, Müller, H., Potsiou, C., Rispoli, E. and Siriba, D. (2019). New Trends in Geospatial Information:The Land Surveyors Role in the Era of Crowdsourcing and VGI. In Y. Doytsher (ed.) International Federation of Surveyors (FIG) Publication No.73. Copenhagen, Denmark. https://www.fig.net/resources/publications/figpub/pub73/figpub73.asp
  5. Counselman C. C, Abbot. III, R. I., Gourevitch, . S. A., King, R. W. and Paradis, A. R. (1983) "Centimeter-level relative positioning with GPS," Journal of Surveying Engineering, 109(2): 81–89.
  6. Dabove, P. (2014) What are the actual performances of GNSS using a smartphone? Inside GNSS Pp1-4 www.insidegnss.com
  7. Dasgpta, A. (2012) Surveying: A radical shift, Geomatics World, Issue 20(6)
  8. De Vries, W. T., Bennett R. M., & Zevenbergen J. A., (2014). "Neo-cadastres: Innovative solution for land users without state based land rights, or just reflections of institutional isomorphism?".Survey Review. 47, 220–229. doi:10.1179/1752270614Y.0000000103.
  9. Egbo, K. (2017). Smart Farming in 2017 and Beyond: Zenvus Smart Farm Technology for Innovative Farming in Africa. Commonwealth Scholar from the UK - Image.
  10. Ekekwe, N. (2018). Survey or Map your Farm, Land and House by Yourself with Zenvus Boundary. TEKEDIA. https://www.zenvus.com/products/boundary/ (accessed March 2022)
  11. El-Ashmawy, K. L. A. (2016). Testing the positional accuracy of OpenStreetMap data for mapping applications. Geodesy and Cartography. Volume 42(1): 25–30
  12. European Standard ISO 19113 (2002) Geographic Information-Quality principles, European Committee for Standardization.
  13. Hossain, M. A., Canning, J., Ast, S., Rutledge, P. J. and Jamalipour A. (2015). Early Warning Smartphone Diagnostics for Water Security and Analysis Using Real-Time pH Mapping, Photonic Sensors Vol. 5 (4): 289–297
  14. Humphreys,T. E. Murrian, M., Diggelen, F., Podshivalov, S., and Pesyna, Jr, K.M. (2016). On the feasibility of cm-accurate positioning via a smartphone’s antenna and GNSS chip. IEEE/ION PLANS Conference Savannah, GA, April 11–14.
  15. Iyiola F., Ogundele, R., Oluwadare, C.O. and Kufoniyi O. (2013). Integrity Check on Ground Control Points Using NIGNET Continuously Operating Reference Stations (CORS). In Proceedings of FIG International Congress, 6-10th May 2013, Abuja Nigeria.
  16. Kerle, N., Janssen, L.F. and Haurneman, G.C. (2004). Principles of Remote Sensing. International Institute for Geo-information Science and Earth Observation, Enschede, The Netherlands.
  17. Laarakker, P. M., & de Vries, W. T. (2011). www.opencadastre.org: exploring potential avenues and concerns. In FIG working week 2011: bridging the gap between cultures: technical programme and proceedings, Marrakech, Morocco, 18-22 May 2011 (pp. 16-). Marrakech: International Federation of Surveyors (FIG).
  18. Lemmen, C., Bennett, R. M., McLaren, R., & Enemark, S. (2015). A new era in land administration emerges. GIM International, 29(1): 22-25.
  19. Liu J.; Chen, R; Pei, L; Guinness, R and Kuusniemi, H. (2012). A Hybrid Smartphone Indoor Positioning Solution for Mobile LBS. Sensors2012 (12) pp 17209-17233. Available at: http://www.mdpi.com/journal/sensors (accessed March 2019)
  20. Mohiuddin S. and Psiaki, M. L. (2007). High-altitude satellite relative navigation using carrier-phase differential global positioning system techniques, Journal of Guidance, Control, and Dynamics, vol. 30 (5):1628-1639, Sept.-Oct.
  21. Navratil, G., & Frank, A. U. (2013). VGI for land administration–a quality perspective.SPRS-International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, 1(1), 159-163.
  22. Oluwadare, C. O. (2016). Assessment of Space-enhanced Systematic Land Titling and Registration in Ondo State, Nigeria. Unpublished Ph. D. Thesis, Department of Geography, Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile- Ife
  23. Oluwadare, C. O. and Oguntade F. O. (2019). Positional accuracy of Zenvus boundary application for cadastral mapping. Proceedings of Environmental Design and Management International Conference. Organized by the Faculty of Environmental Design and Management Obafemi Awolowo University Ile Ife between 20th and 22nd May 2019, Ile –Ife. Pp 605-614
  24. Paek, J.; Kim, J. and Govindan, R. (2010). Energy-efficient rate-adaptive gbs-based positioning for smartphones. In Proceedings of the 8thImternational Conference on Mobile Systems, Applications, and Services (MobiSys’10), June 2010
  25. Pei, L.; Liu, J.; Guinness, R.; Chen, Y.; Kuusniemi , H. and Chen, R. (2012). Using LS-SVM Based Motion Recognition for Smartphone Indoor Wireless Positioning. Sensors 2012 (12) pp 6155-6175 www.mdpi.com/journal/sensors accessed on 7th March 2019.
  26. Pesyna, Jr., K. M., Heath, Jr., R. W. and Humphreys, T. E. (2014) “Centimeter positioning with a smartphone-quality GNSS antenna,” in Proceedings of the ION GNSS+ Meeting.
  27. Pesyna, Jr, K. M. Heath, Jr., R. W. and Humphreys, T. E. (2015) “Accuracy in the palm of your hand: Centimeter positioning with a smartphone quality GNSS antenna,” GPS World, 26(2):16–31
  28. Pratama, K. R.; Widyawan and Hidayat, R. (2012) Smartphone-based Pedestrian Dead Reckoning as an Indoor Positioning System. In Proceedings of International Conference on System Engineering and Technology September 11-12Bandung, Indonesia.
  29. Roberts, C.; Davis-Raiss, P.; Lofberg, D. and Goodman, G. (2013). Is Neo-Cadastral Surveying on your Smart Phone Feasible? In Proceedings of the Surveying & Spatial Sciences Conference April 2013 Canberra, Australia.
  30. Robustelli, U., Baiocchi, V., & Pugliano, G. (2019). Assessment of Dual Frequency GNSS Observations from a Xiaomi Mi 8 Android Smartphone and Positioning Performance Analysis. Electronics, 8(1), 91. MDPI AG. Retrieved from http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/electronics8010091.
  31. Sharma A. & Gupta D. (2014). Smartphone as a Real-time and Participatory Data Collection Tool for Civil Engineers. International Journal of Modern Computer Science (IJMCS) 2 (5): 22-27
  32. Sunda, S., Vyas B. M. , Satish, S.V. Khekale, P. V. and Parikh K.S. (2013). Improvement of positional accuracy with GAGAN
  33. and the impact of scintillation on GNSS. Positioning 4 :282-288.
  34. SURCON (2005). Cadastral Survey Regulations. A publication of Surveyors’ Council of Nigeria.
  35. UN-ECE (1996). “Land Administration Guidelines. Meeting of Officials on Land Administration, UN Economic Commission for Europe”. ECE/HBP/96 Sales No.E.96.II.E.7, ISBN 92-1-116644-6: 1 -111.
  36. Werner, M; Kessel, M and Marouane, C. (2011). Indoor Positioning Using Smartphone Camera. In Proceedings of International Conference on Indoor Positioning and Indoor Navigation (IPIN), 21-23 September, Guimar Aes, Portugal.
  37. Yang, J., Wang, Z., Wang, G.; Liu J and Meng Y.(2007) on Clock jumps of GPS receiver. J Geodes Geodyn vol.27 : 123-127